Homeowners Insurance Cancelled Because of Your Roof?
"I had the same problem. Nobody would provide me homeowners insurance so I had to put on a new roof."
One commenter in a roofing thread wrote that. It is one way it ended, but the letter is a notice with a reason and a date, not a verdict. Check whether it says cancellation or nonrenewal, then find the date and the stated reason. Depending on the state you live in, an insurer that doesn't renew must give you a certain number of days’ notice and explain the reason1 before it drops your policy. Then find out what triggered it and start collecting quotes.
Quick answer:
- Read the letter and write down the word it uses, the date and the reason.
- Read your policy to see what your responsibilities are2 before you call anyone.
- Ask the insurer what triggered the letter and whether an inspection or repair could change it.
- Start collecting quotes from other companies now, because putting off shopping for a new policy1 only shortens your time.
On this page
You control the next few days.
What does the letter actually say?
Look for one word first: cancellation or nonrenewal. If yours says nonrenewal, the number of days depends on your state1. If it says cancellation, ask your state insurance department which notice and reason apply.
Then look for the reason. A letter that blames the roof usually names its age or its condition, and the two lead to different next steps. Age points to shopping and records. Condition points to an inspection and, maybe, repairs.
Not every letter ends coverage. In Texas, as roofs age, some companies switch to actual cash value, and a roof in poor condition might not be covered at all3. So read for a change in coverage as well as an end.
Why an old roof worries insurers
Age gets checked at the door. When you apply for home insurance, most insurance companies will require a roof over 20 years old to pass an inspection4.
With an actual cash value policy5, age also changes what a roof claim can pay. Actual cash value is what the roof is worth after wear, not the price of a new one. The deductible is the part you pay first. Texas gives an example. With a $4,000 deductible on a roof that costs $10,000 to replace, an actual cash value policy pays $4,500 for a 5-year-old roof, $3,000 for a 10-year-old roof and $0 for a 20-year-old roof5. Your numbers will differ.
From the ground, you can look for shingle edges that peel up and curl as asphalt shingles age6. It is one sign of wear, and it does not tell you what your insurer saw.
First steps before you answer
Do these in order. A prepared call goes better than a fast one.
- Read the letter and note the word, the date and the reason.
- Write down what you want to know: what triggered the letter, how many days you have, and whether an inspection or repair could change the decision1.
- Ask those questions, and write down names and dates. In Tennessee, insurers report to a claims database files they set up for a possible claim7, not only claims they pay. If you are only asking about the letter, say that's all you're asking.
- Ask your state insurance department how much notice your state requires for the word on your letter; for a nonrenewal, the number of days depends on the state you live in1.
Wondering what an insurer's roof inspection would look at? Roof inspection for insurance: what will they check.
Can a repair or inspection change the decision?
Sometimes, but nobody can promise it. If a policy isn't renewed because of a failed inspection, making the proper updates could help you maintain coverage1. That is why the stated reason matters: a repair only helps if you know what failed.
Before you pay for any repair, ask the insurer to say in writing which repair or inspection it would accept, who needs to do it and by what date. You can send this:
Please confirm in writing which repair or inspection you would accept for my roof, who must do it, and the date it is due.
State law can limit8 what an insurer can do about roof age. Florida is one example. For a roof at least 15 years old, an insurer must allow a homeowner to have a roof inspection performed by an authorized inspector at the homeowner’s expense8 before requiring replacement. Ask your state insurance department whether your state has a similar rule.
If the insurer asks for work, is a repair enough, or is it a new roof? Roof repair or replacement: how to tell which.
Shop now, and describe the roof accurately
The letter has an end date and quotes take time, so start shopping while you can. One commenter described the order that worked for them:
"I got a similar letter from my home insurance company. Before the end of my contract, I got a new insurance policy (being transparent about the age of my roof)."
Make sure your house is described properly to each company, including the roof's real age and condition. Then the quote you get is for the roof you have. Keep the old policy until the new one starts9, so there is no gap.
Once you have coverage, how would a claim on an older roof be paid? Will insurance cover an older roof.
What if no company will cover you?
A lapse is the part people dread. As one reply in a roofing thread put it, "It’s going to be hard as is to find someone who will cover you."
One fallback exists. FAIR plans are insurance pools that sell property insurance to people who can’t get coverage in the voluntary market10, meaning the regular insurers. Ask what one would cost and cover before you rely on it.
Checklist: is an inspection your next step?
- The letter names the roof's age or condition as the reason.
- You have the date and the reason written down.
- You can't tell what shape the roof is in.
- You haven't agreed to any roofing work yet.
Quick questions
Is it bad if an insurance company cancels your policy? It can be, if it leaves you without coverage: you don’t want coverage on your home to lapse1. Have the new policy running before the old one stops, and end the old one only after the new one is in force9.
How do I find out how old my roof is? Check the paperwork from when the house was bought or when the roof was last replaced, such as an invoice from the roofer. Give your best figure, and say that it is an estimate if it is one.
Does homeowners insurance pay for shingles? Your policy decides, and the cause of the damage matters. Ask whether the roof is paid at replacement cost or at actual cash value, since the Texas example above shows how far apart they can be.
How many days do I have? The date on the letter is the one to plan around. If it is missing or unclear, ask your state insurance department which rules apply to your letter, since the notice an insurer must give depends on the state you live in1.
Sources
2. Insurance Information Institute (Triple-I), "How to file a homeowners claim
5. Texas Department of Insurance, "Home insurance policies: Replacement cost or actual cash value?
6. Insurance Institute for Business & Home Safety, "Natural Weathering and Hazard Exposure
7. Tennessee Department of Commerce and Insurance, "C.L.U.E. (Comprehensive Loss Underwriting Exchange)
8. The Florida Senate, "Florida Statutes, Section 627.7011 (2025)
9. Oklahoma Insurance Department, "Choosing your Homeowners Insurance Policy
10. Insurance Information Institute (Triple-I), "What if I can't get coverage?
Found an error on this page? Email [email protected].